Location: On the Commandments of God and of the Church > The Eighth Commandment
Q1: What does the Eighth Commandment, Thou shalt not bear false witness, forbid?
A1: The Eighth Commandment, Thou shalt not bear false witness, forbids false testimony in a court of justice, and it also forbids backbiting, detraction, calumny, adulation, rash judgement and rash suspicion and every sort of lying.
Q2: What is detraction or backbiting?
A2: Detraction or backbiting is a sin which consists in making known another’s sins and defects without sufficient reason.
Q3: What is calumny?
A3: Calumny is a sin which consists in maliciously attributing to another faults and defects which he did not possess.
Q4: What is adulation?
A4: Adulation is a sin which consists in deceiving another by falsely praising him or others for the purpose of profiting thereby.
Q5: What is rash judgement or rash suspicion?
A5: Rash judgement or rash suspicion is a sin which consists in judging or suspecting evil of others without sufficient foundation.
Q6: What is a lie?
A6: A lie is a sin which consists in asserting as true or false by word or act that which one does not believe to be really the case.
Q7: How many kinds of lies are there?
A7: There are three kinds: The jocose lie, the officious lie, and the malicious lie.
Q8: What is a jocose lie?
A8: A jocose lie is that which is told in jest and without injury to anyone.
Q9: What is an officious lie?
A9: An officious lie is a false statement to benefit oneself or another without injuring anyone else.
Q10: What is a malicious lie?
A10: A malicious lie is a false statement made to the injury of another.
Q11: Is it ever lawful to tell a lie?
A11: It is never lawful to tell a lie, neither in joke, nor for one’s own benefit, nor for the benefit of another, because a lie is always bad in itself.
Q12: What kind of sin is a lie?
A12: A lie when jocose or officious is a venial sin; but when malicious it is a mortal sin if the harm done is grave.
Q13: Is it always necessary to say all one’s mind?
A13: It is not always necessary, especially when he who questions you has no right to know what he demands.
Q14: Is it enough for him who has sinned against the Eighth Commandment to confess the sin?
A14: It is not enough for him who has sinned against the Eighth Commandment to confess the sin; he is also obliged to retract whatever he said when calumniating another, and to repair as far as he can the harm he has done.
Q15: What does the Eighth Commandment command us to do?
A15: The Eighth Commandment commands us to speak the truth at the proper time and place, and, as far as we can, to put a good interpretation upon the actions of our neighbour.
Leave a Reply